Investor loans dive 30.6% as brokers report volumes down 80%

The property services sector trades on transaction volume, not price, and that buyer's agencies are downsizing rapidly as deal flow dries up.
New investor loan commitments plunged 30.6 per cent in the September quarter, with Property Buzz host Phil Tarrant warning the collapse in transaction volumes, rather than price movements, is what is hurting the property services sector.
Speaking on the Property Buzz podcast, Tarrant ran through the headline lending figures: the value of investor lending fell 2.3 per cent to $24.7 billion, first home buyer new loan commitments fell 8.6 per cent over the quarter, and the overall value of new housing loans dropped 15.5 per cent to $81.2 billion.
He acknowledged the counter-argument that the September 2025 quarter was inflated by investors rushing to buy before the 5 per cent deposit scheme commenced, calling it "not untrue". His co-host said that was "an excuse".
Tarrant quoted Kate Bakos, of Pippa, as saying the figures showed the government's attempt to encourage home ownership by winding back investment concessions "had failed spectacularly".
He suggested the September figures still contain legacy activity from around the budget changes. "Let's see what the December numbers look like, because I reckon they're going to be very different," he said, noting he is hearing of some mortgage brokers down 80 per cent in volume and similar reports from buyer's agents.
Volume, not price, is the problem
Tarrant said price falls of a few percentage points are largely survivable for property businesses, but a collapse in transaction numbers is not.
"Think about a real estate agent who may have got a $10,000 commission cheque and is now getting a $9,500 commission cheque because prices have dropped and they've dusted $500. That can be worn," he said. "It's when those cheques dry up completely or [are] eroded massively."
"Transactions are the health and integrity of the property services sector, and I think that is where it's certainly biting most people in this space at the moment."
He said he was hearing of rapid downsizing among buyer's agencies and expected consolidation he had been flagging for several years to now play out.
"It's going to go back to what that industry was: much smaller, more focused, more hands-on, more direct, not a big scale operation, which I think is certainly unsustainable," he said.
Leaders back on the tools
Tarrant said directors and chief executives who had previously been scarce in their offices are now highly visible across real estate practices nationally.
"The owners of these organisations aren't going to have the privileges of not being operators now. They're going to have to be on the front line, very visible, very aware, doing the work," he said, contrasting that with the recent model of large teams with dedicated lead setters and sales staff.
He described a "normalisation" of attitudes across agents, accountants, buyer's agents and conveyancers, with broad acceptance that the market will be tough for some time, but urged the sector against "sitting around with his heads in his hands perpetually complaining about how tough it is".
Banks chase direct business
Tarrant said CBA had lifted market share in its proprietary channel at the expense of broker-originated lending, and that brokers were raising concerns about channel conflict.
He warned borrowers tempted by cashback offers of around $3,000 may lose loan features they rely on, such as offset facilities, in exchange for a sharper rate.
"You don't have anyone looking over your shoulder to make sure you're choosing the right product," he said. "Depending on what you're trying to do and achieve, sharper rate might not necessarily be right for you."
Auction clearance scepticism
Tarrant noted auction results were slightly higher the previous weekend than the one before, suggesting "maybe something's happening".
His co-host pushed back, warning of "clearance rate propaganda", and cited Brisbane as an example where roughly 20 auctions succeeded out of a scheduled figure he put at more than 200, because campaigns were pulled the night before when no bidders registered.
Property Buzz Newsdesk·19 November 2026



Comments